Is progress with North Korea possible under Trump’s style of diplomacy?

11-Feb-2019 Intellasia | The Guardian | 6:00 AM Print This Post

The stakes are high, and deadly serious. But Trump disregards facts, advice, and the interests that keep America safe

The Donald Trump-Kim Jong-un show has been picked up for a second season, which will kick off with a live broadcast from Vietnam at the end of February.

The show’s producers and the TV networks were so thrilled with the first season in Singapore in 2018, the sequel was a no brainer. The thrill of the first ever meeting between leaders from the United States and North Korea – and these two leaders at that – merited round-the-clock coverage. The media was blanketed with breathless analysis for weeks on end, and on the day of the main event analysts in capitals across the globe stayed up all night to watch it live. Who could resist?

Progress or no progress, Trump thinks he controls the narrative

What will happen in the second season? Will Trump get Kim to give up the nukes? Will Kim keep rebuffing Trump? Will they strike a good deal that breaks the decades-long deadlock? Who knows! That’s why it’s such a guaranteed success – the world will be watching either way!

Trump knows his audience. Progress or no progress, he thinks he controls the narrative. At least these talks aren’t being done in secret, like those talks President Obama’s administration held with Iran that actually secured a deal to prevent Iran from getting a nuke … Those were so boring.

Sarcasm aside, it’s hard to take Trump’s attempt at diplomacy with North Korea (or anyone else, for that matter) seriously, as Trump disregards facts, advice and the interests and norms that keep America safe. But the stakes are high, and deadly serious. On North Korea, the only good alternative to the current path is diplomacy by a more competent president. Alas, that’s not in the cards right now.

So here we are. You go to the negotiating table with the team you have.

And so, as Trump and Kim sit down again to talk about the future of nuclear weapons in North Korea and the fate of Korean peninsula, the question remains: is progress possible?

Maybe. Maybe North Korea really wants to change and open up to the world. Maybe the diplomatically skilled South Korean president, Moon Jae-in, can facilitate a breakthrough. Maybe Trump’s unprecedented leader-to-leader engagement will unlock progress.

Or, maybe not. Maybe North Korea is just buying time to relieve sanctions and expand its arsenal. Maybe Trump only cares about making his engagement with North Korea look like a success. Maybe Trump will agree to a bad deal that plays well on TV: Trump brings all US troops home from South Korea (which he has repeatedly indicated an interest in doing) in return for vague promises of denuclearization. And this time, there’s no more Secretary of Defense James Mattis or Chief of Staff John Kelly to try to stop Trump from agreeing to a crazy deal.

The only good alternative to the current path is diplomacy by a more competent president. Alas, that’s not in the cards right now

So far, there’s little evidence that this process will be successful. North Korea continues to advance its nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs. Even since the Singapore summit, North Korea has resisted engaging in the working level talks necessary for any deal – US special representative for North Korea Steve Biegun only met his North Korean counterpart days ago, after the second summit was confirmed.

At least it’s better than “fire and fury”, right? At least we’re not at war. Sure. Compared with war, everything looks good. But the specter of war with North Korea was created by Trump. When Obama left office, conflict was highly unlikely – although dangerous, North Korea has no interest in starting a war and the United States, and its allies have long contained and deterred North Korea. But Trump changed that, threatening to start an unnecessary war. For those who thought it was just bluster, Vincent Brooks, the former commander of US forces in South Korea, recently made clear just how close we were to war. Despite personally heightening the risk of conflict, Trump wants everyone to believe that he saved America from war, as he tweeted after the Singapore summit: “There is no longer a Nuclear Threat from North Korea.” In reality, Trump is both the arsonist and firefighter.

While the chances of success are low, diplomacy with North Korea is necessary – it is the only way that the United States and its allies will address the threat from North Korea. The South Korean government is moving ahead with talks with North Korea, and the US must support its ally in Seoul. I have repeated these lines more times than I can count in the last year, and they remain true.

But we must also recognize that, to date, Trump’s approach is not addressing the problem. Kim ceased testing of nukes and missiles before Trump agreed to diplomacy. Since the diplomacy began, North Korea has only dismantled a test site while continuing to expand its nuclear and missile programs.

The lack of verifiable progress is eroding support for diplomacy on all sides

Even without major breakthroughs it would be nice to believe that this diplomacy could continue indefinitely and keep the hope of progress alive. Genuine incremental progress – probably the best-case scenario – would be great. And the likely outcome of the second summit is more promises that keep the process going, but uncertainty around tangible progress and implementation.

However, the lack of verifiable progress is eroding support for diplomacy on all sides. Diplomacy between North and South Korea is hitting more bumps, with conservatives in South Korea opposed to Moon’s moves. And the longer Trump continues on this path without results to show for it, support for diplomacy in the United States will fall.

As long as Kim maintains the moratorium on testing and there are no regular TV images of missiles that can reach the US being launched, Trump can try to spin his diplomacy as a success. But without verifiable progress soon, viewers may start changing the channel.


Category: Korea

Print This Post