Palace Museum row highlights HK-Beijing tensions

05-Jan-2017 Intellasia | FT | 6:00 AM Print This Post

Territory’s democracy activists cry foul over $450m branch of China’s famed attraction

The decision to build a $450m branch of Beijing’s famed Palace Museum in Hong Kong was meant to celebrate this year’s 20th anniversary of the return of the former British colony to Chinese control and boost its struggling tourist industry.

But the highly symbolic project has run into angry opposition from democracy activists, who have attacked the Hong Kong government for failing to consult the public and promoting a political scheme that undermines the autonomy of the territory.

The dispute over the museum underlines the growing tensions between pro- and anti-Beijing forces in Hong Kong, where the civic freedoms guaranteed by the Chinese government have come under increasing threat.

Carrie Lam, Hong Kong’s top civil servant, announced the plan for the museum, which will feature items loaned from the ancient imperial collections in the Forbidden City, on a trip to Beijing at the end of last year.

Ms Lam, who is gauging Beijing’s support for a possible bid to be Hong Kong’s next leader, said that a public consultation would have been “embarrassing” if there was criticism of such an important project backed by the Chinese government. She insisted the government had followed all the relevant procedures.

The museum will be funded by the Hong Kong Jockey Club, which has a lucrative government-granted monopoly on horse-race betting, thereby circumventing the need for approval from Hong Kong’s legislative council.

James To, an opposition member of the legislature, said the government’s efforts to bypass debate and oversight were “absolutely inappropriate” and would further undermine Hong Kong’s autonomy.

“Ms Lam said that we want to avoid embarrassing the Palace Museum in Beijing but in a pluralistic society, there are those for and against,” he said. “It’s a disaster if we no longer have a free society in Hong Kong.”

Beijing’s Palace Museum is the world’s most visited, with 16m people passing through the Forbidden City, where it is located, last year. Although China’s Communist leaders have had an ambivalent attitude to their imperial history, President Xi Jinping has tried to promote the glories of the past as part of his “great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation”.

Camille Lam, a town planner, said the Hong Kong government should consult the public because it is changing the plans for the West Kowloon Cultural District, where the museum will be built in place of a proposed performance venue.

The decision to build a $450m branch of Beijing’s famed Palace Museum in Hong Kong was meant to celebrate this year’s 20th anniversary of the return of the former British colony to Chinese control and boost its struggling tourist industry.

By signing up you confirm that you have read and agree to the terms and conditions, cookie policy and privacy policy.

But the highly symbolic project has run into angry opposition from democracy activists, who have attacked the Hong Kong government for failing to consult the public and promoting a political scheme that undermines the autonomy of the territory.

The dispute over the museum underlines the growing tensions between pro- and anti-Beijing forces in Hong Kong, where the civic freedoms guaranteed by the Chinese government have come under increasing threat.

Carrie Lam, Hong Kong’s top civil servant, announced the plan for the museum, which will feature items loaned from the ancient imperial collections in the Forbidden City, on a trip to Beijing at the end of last year.

Ms Lam, who is gauging Beijing’s support for a possible bid to be Hong Kong’s next leader, said that a public consultation would have been “embarrassing” if there was criticism of such an important project backed by the Chinese government. She insisted the government had followed all the relevant procedures.

Treasures from the Forbidden City collection on display at a travelling exhibition (C) AFP

The museum will be funded by the Hong Kong Jockey Club, which has a lucrative government-granted monopoly on horse-race betting, thereby circumventing the need for approval from Hong Kong’s legislative council.

James To, an opposition member of the legislature, said the government’s efforts to bypass debate and oversight were “absolutely inappropriate” and would further undermine Hong Kong’s autonomy.

“Ms Lam said that we want to avoid embarrassing the Palace Museum in Beijing but in a pluralistic society, there are those for and against,” he said. “It’s a disaster if we no longer have a free society in Hong Kong.”

Hong Kong’s West Kowloon park, site of the new museum (C) Bloomberg

Beijing’s Palace Museum is the world’s most visited, with 16m people passing through the Forbidden City, where it is located, last year. Although China’s Communist leaders have had an ambivalent attitude to their imperial history, President Xi Jinping has tried to promote the glories of the past as part of his “great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation”.

Camille Lam, a town planner, said the Hong Kong government should consult the public because it is changing the plans for the West Kowloon Cultural District, where the museum will be built in place of a proposed performance venue.

Related article

What does China’s latest intervention mean for Hong Kong?

By unseating elected politicians Beijing has dealt a blow to rule of law

She also accused the government of departing from previous practice by appointing an architect for the project without any open design competition.

“Government officers will do anything to bypass the statutory process,” said Ms Lam, who is a member of the 1,200-strong committee that will nominate candidates to be Hong Kong’s next leader. “We worry that they’re ruining the culture of good governance in Hong Kong.”

Mark O’Neill, a Hong Kong-based historian who has studied Beijing’s Palace Museum, said it was disappointing the proposal had met such opposition.

“Their collection is very prestigious and beautiful and the museum in Hong Kong will attract millions of visitors from Europe and Asia, as well as the mainland,” he said.

O’Neill said China’s leaders would be “very disappointed” by the response to their latest effort to promote patriotism and reverse growing support for a separate Hong Kong identity.

“Beijing will think, ‘we give you a lovely present for Christmas but you still complain’,” he said.

https://www.ft.com/content/47408e62-d173-11e6-9341-7393bb2e1b51

 


Category: Hong Kong

Print This Post

Comments are closed.