US spy agencies collected raw intelligence hinting at public health crisis in Wuhan, China, in November

11-Apr-2020 Intellasia | NBCNews | 6:02 AM Print This Post

US spy agencies collected raw intelligence hinting at a public health crisis in Wuhan, China, in November, two current and one former US official told NBC News, but the information was not understood as the first warning signs of an impending global pandemic.

The intelligence came in the form of communications intercepts and overhead images showing increased activity at health facilities, the officials said. The intelligence was distributed to some federal public health officials in the form of a “situation report” in late November, a former official briefed on the matter said. But there was no assessment that a lethal global outbreak was brewing at that time, a defense official said.

On Wednesday night, the Defense Department disputed an ABC News report that an “intelligence report” had warned about the coronavirus in November.

“We can confirm that media reporting about the existence/release of a National centre for Medical Intelligence (NCMI) Coronavirus-related product/assessment in November of 2019 is incorrect,” said a statement by Dr R. Shane Day, an Air Force colonel who is director of the National centre for Medical Intelligence, a unit of the Pentagon’s Defense Intelligence Agency. “No such NCMI product exists.”

But the current and former officials told NBC News that while no formal assessment was produced in November and hence no “intelligence product,” in the jargon of the spy agencies there was intelligence that caught the attention of public health analysts and fueled formal assessments that were written in December. That material and other information, including some from news and social media reports, ultimately found its way into President Donald Trump’s intelligence briefing book in January. It is unknown whether he read the information.

James Kudla, a spokesman for the Defense Intelligence Agency, declined to comment beyond the NCMI statement.

Air Force Gen. John Hyten, vice chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told reporters Thursday that he did not see intelligence reports on the coronavirus until January.

“We went back and looked at everything in November and December,” he said. “The first indication we have were the reports out of China in late December that were in the public forum. And the first intel reports I saw were in January.”

Even after public health authorities began sounding the alarm in January, the US took few steps to ready itself for a pandemic. There was no effort to boost national stockpiles of medical equipment or encourage social distancing, for example. While Trump touts his decision to stop flights from China coming to the US on January 31, about 381,000 people had flown from China to the US in January, according to an analysis by The New York Times.

Experts believe the coronavirus outbreak began last fall in a seafood market in Wuhan.

The South China Morning Post, citing Chinese government data, reported that the first documented case of someone in China’s suffering from COVID-19, the disease caused by the coronavirus, occurred November 17.

On December 31, an Associated Press report out of China was one of the first English-language news accounts of a mysterious new virus.

“Chinese experts are investigating an outbreak of respiratory illness in the central city of Wuhan that some have likened to the 2002-2003 SARS epidemic,” the story began.

Initially, the World Health Organization was conservative. In a statement about the disease on January 14 discussing the first case outside China, in Thailand the WHO said “there is no clear evidence of human-to-human transmission.”

But by mid-January, it was clear that the virus was spreading well beyond China.

In the US, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention warned Americans on January 6 to take precautions if they were travelling to China. The next day, the CDC’s Emergency Operation centre activated a COVID-19 Incident Management System an emergency management tool used to direct operations, deliver resources and share information.

The extent to which the US intelligence community was warning the White House about the potential implications of the virus remains unclear. Senior congressional aides have told NBC News that the House and Senate intelligence committees did not receive anything that would have constituted an intelligence early warning.

The first House briefing on the coronavirus was February 6, an Intelligence Committee aide said, the day Trump was acquitted in the Senate on impeachment charges.

The Washington Post has reported that US intelligence agencies wrote intelligence reports including ominous warnings about the coronavirus in January and February. None of the classified intelligence reports about the virus have been made public.


Category: China

Print This Post

Comments are closed.